In the aftermath of the Second World War, the League of Nations became
redundant having proven itself to be ineffective in its stated goal of
preventing a second global scale war. Hence, came into existence the United
Nations (UN). The body has, since then, served as the central multilateral
forum where 193 of the 195 countries of the world have a voice. The Holy See
(The Vatican) and the State of Palestine being non-member observer states.
Even
though the foremost stated goal of the UN is fostering international peace,
wars and prolonged conflicts have continued to plague all of humanity. Armed
conflicts have calamitous consequences for non-combatants. Armed groups usually
target civilians as a tool of war. In Rwanda, in 1994, the UN Peacekeeping
Force crumbled under the sheer number of human rights violations.[1]
In Bosnia & Herzegovina the United Nations had a mandate to ‘deter attacks’
on Srebrenica and five other ‘safe areas’. Despite that mandate, up to 20,000
people, overwhelmingly from the Bosnian Muslim community, were killed in and
around the safe areas.[2]
Major General Patrick Cammaert, United Nations Force Commander in Eastern
Democratic Republic of Congo, has this to say about sexual assault in conflict
zones, “Rape is an extremely cheap weapon, but has vast and far-reaching
effects. With the single weapon of rape, soldiers and militants can disrupt and
destroy the fabric of society. Rape sows fear; it spreads sexually transmitted
disease. It excludes women from participation in civic life”.[3]
The UN
mandate of Protection of Civilians (PoC) is a responsibility that encompasses
all spheres of peacekeeping mission; be they civilian, military or police
functions.[4]
Though the first peacekeeping mission was established in 1948, the PoC mandate
came into existence in 1999 when the UN Security Council gave the go-ahead for
the protection of civilians under the UN umbrella due to the deliberate
targeting of civilians in Sierra Leone.
In his report,
the then, UN Secretary General, Ban Ki-Moon in 2010 highlighted the importance
of protection of civilians in UN Peacekeeping Operations (UNPKOs) thereby
ensuring that the state goals of UNPKOs are achieved and the organisation as a
whole is able to maintain its credibility in the long run. Ki-Moon’s statement
underlines why the sanctity of the human rights must be maintained at all
costs. He stated: “We must focus our efforts on enhancing protection where
and for whom it matters most- on the ground, in the midst of conflict and for
the hundreds of thousands of civilians who are, on a daily basis, at risk of,
or fall victim to, serious violations of International Humanitarian Law and
human rights law”.[5]
Over the years
it has become readily apparent that the PoC mandate of the UN is as important
as the peacekeeping mission itself. The protection of lives and maintaining the
dignity of civilians caught between warring factions ensures that half the
battle of peacekeeping is won. In conflict zones, apart from the loss of lives
of civilians the prime targets are women and even girls who face sexual assault
and the families which lose their valuables.
The importance
of the PoC mandate cannot be oversold as it is the only structure in place for
the protection of civilians living in the midst of a zone suffering from
prolonged conflict. In such cases, the collapse of the indigenous system is
eminent and, therefore, a supporting mechanism is required to ensure that the
inevitable cost to the non-combatants be mitigated as much as possible.
Therefore, in
such an environment it becomes an absolute necessity to maintain law and order to
ensure the protection of non-combatants. For such the UN has, under the aegis
of the United Nations Police, constituted three tiers of PoC action which are
enumerated below:
·
The first and foremost is to ensure the
protection of native peoples caught in the middle of a conflict zone. Physical
protection requires the formation of Formed Police Units (FPUs) because of the
Directive on Use of Force and the FPU group’s ability to act as one unit in
armed combat.
·
The second tier is the outreach which the
protectors need to enact with the incumbent authorities which involves the
advocacy of the local police to undertake the responsibility of the protection
of civilians. Further on, it also includes the community-based outreach for the
strengthening community-based policing and engagement of individuals for
recording human rights violations.
·
The third and final tier is the creation of an ecosystem
for protection of civilians. This effectively includes prevention, pre-emption,
response and consolidation mechanism for the assurance of the first two tiers
so that problems can, not only, be dealt with as when they arise but also be
nipped in the bud via the mechanism in the place.
It is indeed
clear that the protection of civilians should be the paramount duty of any
peacekeeping force that hopes to achieve its stated goals of fostering
sustainable peace and reducing conflict in areas which have traditionally
served as hotspots of human rights violations. Therefore, efforts need to be
made on both the institutional and on-ground levels to ensure that the security
and dignity of the civilians within a conflcit-ridden area is maintained because
without ensuring the protection of civilians in such zones the belligerence is
only perpetuated.
Endnotes
[1]
S/1999/1257, Security Council Report, 16 Dec 1999
[2]
Report of Secretary General Pursuant to General Assembly Resolution 53/35: The
Fall of Srebrenica, United Nations Digital Library, 15 Nov 1999
[3]
Major General Patrick Cammaert, PeaceWomen, accessed on 7 Nov 2023
[4]
Protection of Civilians, United Nations, accessed on 07 Nov 2023
https://peacekeeping.un.org/en/protection-of-civilians-mandate
[5]
Michael G Smith, Jeni Whalan & Peter Thomson, The Protection of Civilians
in UN Peacekeeping Operations: Recent Developments, JSTOR, accessed on 7 Nov
2023
https://www.jstor.org/stable/26467114?seq=1
Vinayak Sharma is a Research Assistant at the United Service Institution. And has done extensive research on the United States, Russia, China and the Central Asian Region. He is a graduate in Mass Communication from Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan and is pursuing M.A. in Defence Studies from Chaudhary Charan Singh University.
Uploaded on 09-11-2023
Disclaimer: The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the organisation that he/she belongs to or of the USI of India.