Back

Darfur Model of Hybrid Mission: will it succeed

Col R K Rajput
 


While the recent visit of UN Secretary General Ban Ki – moon to Sudan brought some hope and cheer for the long suffering people of Darfur it remains to be seen as to how much of the promises made by both, the Sudanese govt and the UN are kept to keep their hopes alive. Reacting to the appeals made by The UNSG, the Sudanese govt promised to do its utmost to implement the Jan 2005 Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA) and ensure provision of essential relief services by the aid agencies in Darfur. The UN also pledged to deploy United Nations Assistance Mission in Darfur (UNAMID) as quickly as possible to provide peace and stability in Darfur and support CPA and better North –South relations.

The UN is currently implementing a three-phased approach to bolster African Union Mission in Sudan AMIS) and deploy a robust peacekeeping force in Darfur. The approach consists of measures to augment AMIS in the form of a Light Support Package (LSP), a Heavy Support Package (HSP), and culminates in the AU/UN Hybrid operation in Darfur (UNAMID). Each phase has required its own set of agreements and understandings among the UN, the AU and the Government of Sudan. In order to reach these, the UN has undertaken a complex round of negotiations, including on the level and type of support, issues of command and control, and the legal framework governing the effort. UNAMID represents a unique model of partnership for peacekeeping between the UN and a regional organization.

The Light Support Package (LSP) provides support to the management capacity of AMIS and consists of 105 military staff officers, 34 police advisers, and 48 civilians, as well as material and equipment. While the majority of the LSP had been deployed as of the end of Aug 2007, the dispatch of 36 armoured personnel carriers was still pending. It is, however, envisioned that these vehicles will be deployed to Darfur in tandem with an additional two battalions provisionally scheduled to arrive towards the end of 2007.

The Heavy Support Package (HSP), to be deployed in the second half of 2007, is designed to support AMIS until the Hybrid operation deploys and comprises 2,250 military, 721 police and 1,136 civilians at a cost of US $287.9 million to be
Funded by the UN. Preference is to be accorded to African troops. If no suitable African personnel are found, the UN will strive to find capable personnel of countries acceptable to all the parties.

The Security Council had earlier approved the creation of a hybrid United Nations-African Union peacekeeping force On 31 July 2007 to quell the violence and instability plaguing the Darfur region of Sudan, where hundreds of thousands of people have been killed and two million others forced to flee their homes.

In what Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon called a “historic and unprecedented resolution,” Council members unanimously backed the establishment of a force of nearly 20,000 military personnel and more than 6,000 police officers.

The hybrid operation – to be known as UNAMID – has an initial mandate of 12 months and will incorporate the existing AU Mission in Sudan (AMIS), which has been deployed across Darfur since 2004. It will become the largest peacekeeping force in the world.

By October 2007, UNAMID is scheduled to have its management, command and control structures in place, and then by the end of the year it is expected to be ready to take over operations from AMIS.

Since fighting erupted between rebel groups, Government forces and allied Janjaweed militias in 2003, UN officials have repeatedly described Darfur as the scene of one of the world’s worst humanitarian crises. More than 200,000 people have been killed and the conflict has spilled into neighbouring Chad and the Central African Republic (CAR).

UNAMID is tasked with acting under Chapter VII of the UN Charter to support the “early and effective implementation” of last year’s Darfur Peace Agreement between the Government and the rebels, and it is also mandated to protect civilians, prevent armed attacks and ensure the security of aid workers and its own personnel and facilities.

Command and control structures and backstopping for UNAMID will be provided by the UN, and the operation will also have a single chain of command.

While cooperation by govt of Sudan, availability of water, infrastructure and other resources as well as funds will dictate if the mission can be deployed within the stipulated timeframe, one single most factor which stands out as a possible roadblock , unless all the heads think alike, is the functioning of the proposed Hybrid peacekeeping force.

Rodolphe Adada of the Republic of the Congo has been appointed Joint AU-UN Special Representative (JSR) designate for Darfur to lead UNAMID. He will report to both the UN Secretary-General and the AU Commission Chairperson. The JSR is assisted by a jointly appointed Deputy Special Representative designate, Henry Anyidoho of Ghana. Directives to the JSR will be issued through the AU Peace and Security Commissioner and the UN Under-Secretary-General for Peacekeeping Operations. The day-to-day functioning of the force will be in accordance with the concept of operations which has been jointly agreed upon by the AU and the UN. That is, in accordance with agreements made in Addis Ababa and Abuja in 2006, and as specified in the joint report on the Hybrid operation from June 2007, the command and control structures for the mission will be provided by the UN.

General Martin Luther Agwai of Nigeria has been appointed Force Commander designate of UNAMID by the AU, in consultation with the UN, and will report to the JSR. Prior to the deployment of UNAMID, General Agwai will command the AMIS force. The same appointment procedure and reporting lines will apply to the UNAMID Police Commissioner. The AU and the UN strategic headquarters will ensure effective consultation through a Joint Support Coordination Mechanism (JSCM) in Addis Ababa, which will consist of a number of liaison officers and communications equipment.


The AU experience in Ethiopia-Eritriea, Burundi, and in Sudan itself has been of a mixed nature. While various regional organizations have worked alongside the UN forces, either prior to or after the deployments of a UNPK force in a mission area, with varying degree of success, the current arrangement of proposed hybrid force is a unique one. Even in a regular UN mandated mission the leadership has a great difficulty keeping all its UN elements and agencies together to work towards a common goal. Here, the SRSG and Force Commander will require special skills to implement the planned command and control arrangements and ensure everybody tows the designated line. It may have been better to assign separate responsibilities to UN and AU forces by augmenting the resources of AMIS. Soldiers wearing twin hats of UN and AU will only add to the confusion and heartburns when it comes to terms and conditions of the two and specially the financial emoluments. Only time will tell if this new experiment by the UN succeeds or the people of Darfur will have to wait even longer before they can live in peace.

 

 

                                                                                             Back
 

Copyright © United Service Institution of India
Website By IITPL